"I Want You Back" Review: This Ones A Keeper!
I Want You Back is a great choice for a good laugh on Amazon Prime! It’s a good spirited, romantic comedy that’s just in time for Valentine’s Day weekend. While it is a little long for the conventional film of its kind, the plot development is hysterical enough to keep you engaged from scene to scene. It hits all the right notes of a modern rom-com and dare I say could be a classic!
The film gets straight into the action with a break up between two couples: Emma (Jenny Slate) and Noah (Scott Eastwood), and Anne (Gina Rodriguez) and Peter (Charlie Day). Feeling emotional from their breakup, Emma and Peter retreat to the office building’s stairwell one day to have a good cry and meet each other in their grief. This chance meeting turns into a friendship in which the two lament about their exes and eventually hatch a plan to get them back. Peter will befriend Noah and remind him of the one who got away. Emma will try to seduce Logan (Manny Jacinto), Anne’s new boyfriend, and cause Anne to run back to Peter. At least, that’s the plan!
Slate and Day are laugh-out-loud funny with spitball comedy chemistry! Emma and Peter are fully realized characters on screen. You can almost write in their histories yourself based on the way they move through life, the decisions they make, and their dialogue. Emma suffers from a bit of arrested development (her roommates are young college students because she can’t afford the rent on her own) and she’s a hopeless romantic. Peter has a heart for the elderly but lacks confidence in chasing his dreams. The banter between the two is a game of tennis that is exciting to watch.
Director Jason Orley pays particular attention to the frame within this film. Leading lines point to his characters in the stairwell, sitting at a cafe, standing in a crowd or changing in a changing room. The mise-en-scene (stage design and arrangement of actors) in the film is noteworthy for a comedy in this genre, which isn’t something I would usually say. No, this isn’t high art, but there is care and intention in the frame. So what does it do for the film? It helps with the character and scene development. For instance, in a scene where Emma and Peter hash out their plan, they are sitting in a courtyard in front of a giant building. The building dwarfs them in scope while emphasizing the big plan they’re putting together. In another scene, Anne and Logan face each other in the foreground while Emma stands in between them in the background. The framing of shots mean something in many scenes which is refreshing to see.
Editing doesn’t get enough love in well executed rom-coms. Editor Jonathan Schwartz has as much to do with the comedic timing as Day and Slate. The film gives us what we need to know about a particular moment and cuts to the next event. It’s the choice of cuts- whether jumps, crosscuts, fades or smash cuts- that work to further the film’s laughs. A cut from an emotionally sweet moment during a children’s musical to men spraying champagne in a club is a part of the beautiful, unexpected mashup of thought this film is at times.
In short, I Want You Back fires on all cylinders from top to bottom. At its core, writers Isaac Aptaker and Elizabeth Berger have shaped a story that understands tropes of the past and looks to circumvent them. When it does fall into cliché it earns the moment. The film has a long-running time just under two hours, but the sketches of comedy built-in getting there is worth the ride. This film is a keeper!
Rating: A-
